Pain vs. Suffering: What Chronic Pain Taught Me About Rest
Right now, roughly 1 in 5 adults worldwide are living with chronic pain — here in Australia alone, that's an estimated 3.6 million people (International Association for the Study of Pain; Chronic Pain Australia, National Pain Report 2025). I'm one of them.
Ready for a recharge? Check out the RESET toolkit below
There's a particular kind of hope that comes with a good day. You wake up, and the chronic pain you've carried for years feels quieter, further away, almost forgettable. And before you've even had your coffee, a thought arrives, bright and certain: I feel great! let's do a gym class and hit 10k steps today.
I know my own pain well enough to usually read it — until a recent, more acute episode threw that off completely. Was a good morning proof I'd turned a corner, or just the quiet before the next one? Unable to tell the difference, I kept throwing myself back in fully, only to be met with something harder each time. Rest just long enough to feel capable, then repeat the whole loop again.
Each round came with its own scramble — cancelled plans (sorry, book club), extra childcare hours booked, work reshuffled apologetically — and its own quiet frustration underneath. I was disappointed. Grumpy. Impatient with a body that wouldn't cooperate on my timeline. Some of it was frustration at letting people down — the friends I'd cancelled on, the extra childcare I'd had to pay for, the colleagues stepping up and covering for me. And some of it was something harder to admit: feeling let down by my own body, as though it had broken a promise I hadn't realised I was counting on.
There was another voice too, quieter and harsher than the other two. It took my exhaustion and relabelled it laziness. On the days I couldn't keep up, I wasn't just tired — I was falling short. I'd catch myself scrutinising my own output the way a strict manager might scrutinise an underperforming employee, as though rest were an excuse I hadn't earned the right to use.
What eventually broke the loop wasn't more willpower or more caution. It was real, unhurried rest — and a kind of equanimity with whatever the sensation actually was that day, rather than treating a good morning as a verdict to act on. If you've lived with chronic pain a long time, you'll recognise this: a sharper flare up doesn't come with the wisdom your old pain did. It can feel like starting over.
Why Rest Feels Like Something You Have to Earn
Maybe your version of this doesn't involve steps at all. Maybe it's the week you finally feel like yourself again, so you say yes to every request that's been piling up, run all the errands, overexert yourself. Maybe it's the good day that convinces you the bad days are over, so you stop pacing yourself and go back to full speed (or more!) by instinct. Maybe it's not physical pain but a kind of emotional or mental exhaustion — a good week that tempts you to fill every evening again, spread yourself thin, right after you swore you'd protect your evenings and your energy better from now on.
Few of us grew up with role models who rested before they had to — who paused on a good day instead of pushing straight through it. Without that example, we learn the opposite by default: that rest is something you earn through collapse, not legitimate until you've proven you truly need it. We treat recovery like a pit stop wedged into the gaps between productivity, a quick refuel rather than what it actually is: the process that makes the next stretch of road possible at all.
You're not alone in this pattern, and you're not broken for having fallen into it just as I recently did. Almost none of us were ever taught another way. You're one of the hundreds of millions I mentioned at the start — doing this same quiet, largely invisible work today.
What's actually happening in the body
It turns out the pattern I kept living has a name. Physiotherapists and pain researchers call it the boom-bust cycle, and it's one of the most well-documented patterns in people managing pain, injury, or chronic illness: you feel capable, you overdo it, you flare up, you rest just enough to feel capable again, and the cycle repeats. It's not a character flaw. It's what happens naturally when we take "feeling good" as our only signal for how much to do.
The evidence-based alternative isn't more willpower, and it isn't more caution either. It's pacing — structuring activity and rest in planned, sustainable amounts based on what the body can actually recover from, rather than on how good today happens to feel. Research on activity pacing consistently finds that people who build rest into their plans proactively, rather than collapsing into it only once they've hit a wall, recover more steadily and flare up less often than people caught in the boom-bust loop — even when both groups are equally motivated to get well.
There's a physiological reason deep, complete rest matters so much here. Tissue repair and the nervous system's return to a calm baseline are both active biological processes, not simply the absence of activity — the body is doing real work while it looks like it's doing nothing. Cutting that process short doesn't just delay it. For many of us, it resets it, which is exactly why "just enough" rest so reliably leads straight back to another crash instead of to solid ground.
When your own signals can't be fully trusted
Here's the part I wish someone had explained to me earlier: living with chronic pain and inflammation doesn't just give you pain. Over time, it can quietly recalibrate the very instruments you'd normally use to gauge how you're doing.
Researchers call one piece of this central sensitization — a process in which a nervous system that's been dealing with pain for a long stretch becomes more reactive, not less, so your pain threshold shifts and ordinary exertion can register as far more significant than it used to, sometimes well after the activity that triggered it. Chronic inflammation also has a well-documented relationship with fatigue that has nothing to do with how much you've done that day — inflammatory cytokines act directly on the brain to produce exhaustion, which is part of why a "good" morning's energy can evaporate by early afternoon for reasons that feel like they came from nowhere. And underneath both of those, there's interoception — the felt sense of what's happening inside your own body — which research shows can become less accurate, not more, the longer someone lives with chronic pain, precisely because the signal has been so noisy for so long.
Put together, that means the very thing "listen to your body" asks you to rely on — an accurate, trustworthy internal read — is often exactly what chronic pain and inflammation compromise. That good-day feeling I kept trusting wasn't lying to me out of nowhere. It was information from instruments that chronic pain had already thrown out of calibration. That's not a reason to give up on listening to your body. It's a reason to stop expecting that listening, on its own, will always be enough.
Pain vs. Suffering: The Distinction That Changes Everything
What's still reliable, even when the details are noisy, is your capacity to simply notice — to meet a sensation with curiosity instead of an instant verdict. That's where mindfulness of the body becomes less a wellness buzzword and more a practical tool: it separates the raw sensation from everything we stack on top of it. Pain and suffering aren't the same thing, and learning to tell them apart changes what "listening to your body" can actually offer you.
Jon Kabat-Zinn, who developed Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction specifically for people living with chronic pain, found something counterintuitive in his early clinical work: patients' pain intensity often didn't shift all that much, but their suffering did — sometimes dramatically — once they learned to meet the sensation with open, non-judgmental attention instead of bracing against it or resenting it. Psychologist Steven Hayes, who developed Acceptance and Commitment Therapy, describes a similar split between "clean pain" and "dirty pain." Clean pain is the sensation itself — real, often unavoidable, information from a body doing its job. Dirty pain is the layer we stack on top of it: the tension of fighting it, the shame of having a body that hurts, the fear that spins a single flare-up into a spiral of self-criticism. We can't always control the first layer. We have far more influence over the second than we tend to believe.
Where inflammation fits in
It helps to understand what's actually happening beneath a flare-up, because inflammation itself isn't the villain of this story — it's the body's repair crew, arriving at the site of strain or injury to clear damage and rebuild tissue. The problem isn't that inflammation shows up. It's what happens when it never gets the chance to finish its job.
Researchers who study the resolution of inflammation have shown that resolving inflammation is an active process, not simply inflammation fading out on its own. It has a beginning, a job to do, and an end, and that end requires time and genuine rest to complete. Every time we push back into full activity before that process has finished, we don't just risk re-injury — we retrigger the inflammatory response before the last one has resolved, which is a large part of why boom-bust flare-ups can feel progressively worse rather than staying the same.
Chronic stress compounds this. Decades of research in psychoneuroimmunology have shown that an activated stress response — the kind that comes with pushing through pain, guilt about resting, or a to-do list that never quiets down — raises circulating inflammatory markers like IL-6 and CRP in its own right. Which means the mental load of feeling bad about needing to rest isn't just uncomfortable. It may be quietly feeding the very inflammation you're trying to recover from. Genuine rest — the kind that also eases the stress response, not just the activity — appears to matter for this reason too.
The part that's harder to talk about
I want to be honest about something the tidy version of this story leaves out: rest is not equally available to everyone, and it would be dishonest of me to write as though it were. If you're caring for small children or an ageing parent, working a job with no flexibility, or managing a body and a bank balance that don't leave room for a quiet week off, "just rest deeply" can land as one more thing you're failing at rather than genuine permission.
What I've found is that pacing doesn't have to mean grand gestures. It can mean protecting ten minutes between meetings instead of filling them. It can mean choosing to sit rather than stand through the school pickup line, or asking for help with the one task that would let you lie down for twenty minutes this afternoon instead of tonight. Deep rest is the ideal, but deliberate rest — chosen ahead of time, in whatever size is actually available to you — is what pacing is built from. Small, planned, protected rest beats no rest every time, and it beats collapse-and-recover every time too.
Practical ways to start
Separate the pain from the suffering. When a sensation shows up, try naming it neutrally — sharp, dull, tight, tired — before any story about what it means. The sensation is information; the fear, shame, or self-criticism you add on top is optional. Curiosity gives you more useful information than judgment does.
Decide your "enough" before you start, not in the middle of feeling good. On a good day, it's tempting to let the good feeling set the ceiling. Instead, decide in advance — the night before, or first thing in the morning — what a sustainable amount of activity looks like today, and treat that decision as more trustworthy than the mood of the moment.
Build rest in before you need it. Rather than waiting for pain to force a stop, schedule small pockets of real rest into your week the way you'd schedule anything else non-negotiable. Prevention is quieter than recovery, but it costs far less.
Use a permission script. Something as simple as "resting now is what lets me keep going later" can interrupt the guilt that shows up the moment you consider stopping. Say it out loud if you need to. Write it somewhere you'll see it.
Redefine what counts as rest when big rest isn't available. Ten minutes with your eyes closed, a short walk instead of a run, a meeting taken sitting down instead of standing — these count. Perfect rest that never happens helps no one; imperfect rest that actually happens does.
Lean on external markers while you're recalibrating. If a recent, more intense episode has left you unable to trust your old sense of the line, borrow structure from outside yourself for a while — a physio or GP's guidance, a conservative time or distance cap you increase gradually and deliberately rather than by feel, a written plan you follow even on the days that feel deceptively good. You don't need to trust your instincts again before you're ready. You just need something steady to hold onto until you do.
Before you go
Pain, it turns out, was rarely the whole problem. Suffering — the fighting, the shame, the rush to fix it — was often doing more damage than the sensation itself. Here's the line I keep coming back to: the crash isn't proof that you're not trying hard enough — it's proof that rest hasn't been given the same seriousness as effort.
This week, I'd invite you to notice your own version of the boom-bust cycle — the good day that tempts you toward 10k steps, the good week that tempts you to say yes to everything. You don't need to break the pattern all at once. Just notice it, once, before you act on it.
And if you're willing, I'd love to hear where this shows up for you. What does your own feel-good-do-too-much-crash cycle look like — and what would it take to catch it one step earlier next time? Come tell me in the comments below.
Your body has been asking for this rhythm the whole time. This week, maybe just try believing it.